DD202 Dissertation

Critical Social Insurance plan


Young adults 'as risk' or young adults 'at risk': Comparing discourses of anti-social behaviour in the uk and Exito

Nathan Hughes

Critical Cultural Policy 2011 31: 388

DOI: 15. 1177/0261018311405011

The web version of this article can be found at:


Published simply by:


Additional services and information pertaining to Critical Sociable Policy can be found: Email Notifies: http://csp.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts

Subscribers: http://csp.sagepub.com/subscriptions

Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav

Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav

Citations: http://csp.sagepub.com/content/31/3/388. refs. html

> > Type of Record - Jul 21, 2011

What is This kind of?

Downloaded by csp. sagepub. com at Open College or university Library about April 31, 2013



College or university of Greater london

Young people ‘as risk' or young people ‘at risk':

Contrasting discourses of anti-social behavior

in England and Victoria


Dominant discourses regarding problems with anti-social behaviour in the uk and Exito, Australia, uncover counterposed points of views; the former placement anti-social behaviour as a problem of regulation and order and action of worries with criminal offenses and victimization, and the second option emphasizing worries with the weeknesses of the criminal. These opposing perspectives undoubtedly give rise to substantially different policies and affluence. In England, a great emphasis on the needs with the victim categorizes the prevention of particular behaviours, whilst interventions in Victoria keep pace with address the needs in the perpetrator which have been seen to contribute to or result from anti-social behaviour. To illustrate this kind of contrast, the paper illustrates the particular associated with these contradictory discourses upon young people, and doing so implies a need to get wary of the effect of resulting approaches on those who could possibly be most vunerable to committing anti-social behaviour, or having their particular behaviour classed as such.

Key phrases:    Australia, comparative, offense, respect, children

In the UK, over the last decade, the term ‘anti-social behaviour' has moved from a political buzzword into common parlance and vernacular. Referred to as Tony Blair's ‘crusade' (Blair, 2004 cited by Squires, 2006), dealing with anti-social actions became central to Fresh Labour plan post-1997. The Anti-Social Conduct Order (and even more so their acronym, ‘the ASBO') relatively gained a universal recognition amongst the British public, unlike that of any other criminal or civil purchase. The political election of the Conservative-Liberal coalition federal government in May 2010 brought an end to 13 years of Fresh Labour government


© The Author(s), 2011. Reprints and permissions: http://www.sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav Critical Social Policy, 0261-0183 tips; Vol. 31(3): 388–409; 405011 10. 1177/0261018311405011 http://csp.sagepub.com

Downloaded from csp. sagepub. com at Open University Catalogue on The spring 30, 2013

H U G L E S — ‘ A H R I S T ' O R ‘ AT L I H K '

in the united kingdom. Inevitably this kind of led to quick and significant changes to lots of the key, range topping policies from the outgoing authorities. One such transform has found the derogation of the ASBO. In announcing this annulation, Home Secretary Theresa Might criticized these kinds of interventions if you are ‘complex and bureaucratic', and so difficult to put in force. Signifying an apparent potential departure via previous tricks of tackling anti-social behaviour, May possibly called for approaches that are ‘rehabilitating and restorative rather than criminalising and coercive' (May, 2010). Given a great apparent hunger for change, it is therefore well-timed to seriously reflect after New Work policy pertaining to anti-social behaviour and to consider the potential for redirection.

A study of six European countries (ADT Europe, 2006, cited

by simply Crawford, 2008) suggests...

Citations: http://csp.sagepub.com/content/31/3/388. refs. html

> > Version of Record - Jul 21, 2011

What is This kind of?

Downloaded by csp. sagepub. com for Open School Library on April 30, 2013

moved from a political buzzword into common parlance and vernacular. Identified as Tony Blair's ‘crusade' (Blair, 2004 cited by Squires,

2006), tackling anti-social actions became central to New Labour

В© The Author(s), 2011. Reprints and accord: http://www.sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav

Essential Social Insurance plan, 0261-0183 information; Vol


Downloaded coming from csp. sagepub. com for Open College or university Library on April 40, 2013

A survey of six European countries (ADT The european countries, 2006, offered

by Crawford, 2008) suggests that this growing public concern with

Political and public involvement in anti-social behavior is also noticeable

outside of Europe, and notably in Australia (Bor et 's., 2004; Intelligent

et approach., 2004; White, 2007). Right now there appears to be benefit, therefore , in

comparing the rationales, discourses and techniques of different jurisdictions in trying to address anti-social behaviour, particularly

As mentioned by Pierson (2003: 80), ‘Britain and Australia happen to be geographically rather distant, although this physical separation is outweighed

by ties of the past, culture, kinship and language'

Doling (1999) offers a useful categorization of comparative social policy

analysis based on the emphasis on ‘context', ‘content' or ‘consequences'.

Downloaded from csp. sagepub. com at Wide open University Selection on Apr 30, 2013



Factors of Committing Crimes Essay

WHY CARRY OUT PEOPLE DEVOTE CRIMES? Lisette M. A Ivy Bridge College Of Tiffin University or college You're sitting in your living room viewing the news…...

Neural Mechanisms in Handling Eating Behaviour Essay

Outline and evaluate the position of nerve organs mechanisms in controlling consuming behaviour (24 marks) Today there is enormous interest in the psychological factors that can impacts a…...

Behaviourist Theory Essay

Behaviorism: a school of psychology that restricts the study of human nature to what can be seen rather than to states of consciousness. An alternative to the materialist view…...



To Get rid of a Mockingbird Ch. 18 Summary Article

To Kill A Mockingbird: Chapter 18 Mayella is called for the witness stand. She looks like she tries to keep clean, in contrast to her father and…...

Sexual Harrassment Essay

Sexual Harassment Sexual harassment is an ethical concern that happens more frequently that we think. In the workplace sex harassment has become so severe that most ladies are…...

Bureaucracy Article

Paperwork is derived from the phrase bureau, The original French that means of the term " bureau" was the baize used to cover desks. The term bureaucracy came into…...

Meat: an important Part of Human Diet Dissertation

Meat is usually an essential portion of the human diet. Meat and its by-products are the only total sources of proteins available to us. All other forms of protein will…...

Article for the Power of Words Essay

The " Power of Words" copyright 1996 Morgan Workshop group is usually an useful article written by Rebecca T. Morgan publisher of " The Unhappy Crowd", 1961, Yale Univ.…...


Credit: you unit Period: 17 several hours COURSE DESCRIPTION This Discipline Study course 2 is made to provide FS students with opportunities to connect teaching-learning theories…...